College Preparation

Do Net Price Calculators Estimate the Real Cost of College?

[fa icon="calendar"] May 24, 2017 3:41:00 PM / by Robert Brinkman

Robert Brinkman


There are countless articles about the price of a college education. Their chief subject – tuition costs.

Yet many of these articles tend to confuse college tuition cost with the net cost of college – which is what you will actually pay for an academic year. That’s one of the main reasons all U.S. colleges are now required to include a "Net Price Calculator" on their official school website.

While they’re designed to help parents and students estimate the amount of financial aid they could potentially receive from an institution (thus estimating the "net price"), the actual benefit for families is perhaps not very meaningful.

Do Net Price Calculators Really Estimate the “Real” Cost of College?

Net Price Calculators are exactly what you would expect. You punch in information about yourself, your family’s finances, where you plan to live while going to school, etc. After all the info is entered, you’re expecting to discover approximately what you might pay per year for any degree a college offers.

(If you haven’t heard of these before, don’t feel like you’ve been out of the loop. The Federal Government only recently required, as of October 31, 2011, that all colleges and universities list one on their website.)

They MAY provide some basic estimates

Some of the items they cover include paying in-state tuition versus out-of-state tuition, living on-campus versus living off-campus, or living with your parents, how much you expect to take out in loans, or how much you can expect to receive in scholarships/grants.

However, it’s what is left out of the calculations that could be potentially risky for families. For starters, many of the calculators ask too few questions, which could produce inaccurate numbers for some families.

Jeff Whorley, president of a firm that creates custom calculators for 45+ colleges, agrees with critics. His company analyzed the federal calculator using 145,000 actual student profiles and found it to be inaccurate 65% of the time.

You also want to keep in mind that schools only have to follow minimum criteria for what they provide. In other words, it’s at the school’s discretion as to how in-depth they want these tools to get. For example, what many of them don’t outright tell you is how much less you will actually pay when scholarships and grants are factored in.

Additionally, families aren’t at all clued into how they can potentially lower their out-of-pocket costs. (Remember, colleges are businesses, too… and it’s not in their best interest for you to know how to lower the cost of attending their institution.)

What’s more – they do not show parents how to pay for these costs without jeopardizing the rest of their overall financial planning goals. (The only option colleges typically give are loan programs, which often times can be an additional revenue source for the college.)

Do take these calculators with a grain of salt. They are far from being a comprehensive resource. There are a lot more steps that are necessary – yet largely overlooked by the majority of college-bound high school students.


Topics: College Funding, Prepare for College, Planning for College

Robert Brinkman

Written by Robert Brinkman

Rob Brinkman is the Founder of Safe Harbour Retirement, LLC and has been an Advisor for 31 years, opening his first investment firm for Edward Jones in 1987. He has been a Registered Principal and Executive for one of the largest Investment/Insurance companies in the world. He speaks Internationally and was selected by Jim Collins, author of the New York Times Best Selling book Built to Last, to panel his pre-release of the again Best Selling book Good to Great. For the past decade Rob has been focusing on mentoring and coaching business owners and the high net-worth on how to leverage their success more toward a life of meaning and significance. An expert with tax and investment issues, he writes blogs and produces video ‘white boards’ for numerous websites every month.

Follow us on Social Media

Subscribe to Blog Updates

Follow us on Social Media

Recent Posts

I'd like to know more